Biomass and metabolite data for study Gibberellins 1

Selected Cell

Cell:

Value:

Read.ME Biomass Summary Metabolite Data, stats Metabolite Summary

Biomass data from study Gibberellins 1
conducted by Yin Hoon Chew, University of Edinburgh
Metabolite analysis by Virginie Mengin et al, MPIMP.
Sheets in this workbook	Contents
Biomass Summary	mean dry and fresh biomass at day 35 of Col and prr7prr9, control or GA-treated, with SD, charts, derived from GA_Biomass of full sets_AJM.xlsx
Metabolite Data, stats	Metabolite data for individual samples for end of day and end of night, day 28, Col and prr7prr9, n=3 with mean and SD and t-test stats
Metabolite Summary	charts derived from data in Metabolite Data, stats


note on GA-treated Col at day 35, and biomass data
The Col plants flowered early when treated with GA, as expected, mostly between day 28 and day 35
The flowering risked complicating the biomass measurements at day 35, so the Col control plants tested for dry (and fresh) mass were the last 4 to be pre-flowering.
In hindsight, this sampling caused a severe bias towards the youngest i.e. smallest plants in only this genotype-treatment combination, whereas poorly-growing or outlier plants were avoided in normal sampling
GA did not appear to stimulate the biomass of Col in this biased sample, relative to the control, contradicting expectation from the literature.

However when the mean FW of all Col plants was included in the comparison (both for control and GA-treated; 'Full Sets'), not just the 5/4 with DW data, GA stimulated the biomass of Col in line with expectation, and of both Col and prr7prr9 genotypes similarly
Therefore the mean water content of the 4 Col GA plants with DW data was applied to estimate DW for all the Col GA plants, to allow a less-biased comparison of DW in Col control versus GA

The early flowering of Col GA didn't affect the sampling of plants for metabolite measurements at day 28, as the plants hadn't flowered.

Photoperiod	12	h
Temperature		deg C

Sets of plants with dry mass and images					Sets of plants with dry mass and images						Full sets								For plotting
n=5					n=5 (except Col with GA treatment, n = 4)														Put DW on secondary Y axis! Move columns to right??!

Genotype	Control		+ GA		Genotype	Control		+ GA			Genotype	Control			+ GA				Genotype	Control (n=5)		+GA (n=5)		Control (n=15,40)		+GA (n=21,38)
	FW	SD	FW	SD		FW	SD	FW	SD			FW	SD	n	FW	SD				FW	SD	FW	SD	FW	SD	FW	SD
Col (n=5)	0.9211599999999999	0.10272065517703825	1.0466799999999998	0.2183955745888641	Col	0.9211599999999999	0.10272065517703825	0.9572749999999999	0.10152409812453395		Col (n=15,21)	0.8215666666666664	0.11767017261740342	15	1.2193571428571428	0.1783744252168144	21		Col FW	0.9211599999999999	0.10272065517703825	1.0466799999999998	0.2183955745888641	0.8215666666666664	0.11767017261740342	1.2193571428571428	0.1783744252168144
prr7prr9 (n=5)	0.4843400000000001	0.030674305208105417	0.7672400000000001	0.07878529685163337	prr7prr9	0.4843400000000001	0.030674305208105417	0.7672400000000001	0.07878529685163337		prr7prr9 (n=40,38)	0.45172750000000017	0.06371448326875914	40	0.7733763157894737	0.08351160280030497	38		prr7prr9 FW	0.4843400000000001	0.030674305208105417	0.7672400000000001	0.07878529685163337	0.45172750000000017	0.06371448326875914	0.7733763157894737	0.08351160280030497
																			Col estDW					0.07103391077758296	0.010173943128438459	0.10088839412549006	0.014758522077473149
																			prr7prr9 estDW					0.04766016384001818	0.006722288794840156	0.0733605602015603	0.007921703625623172














																	Water content at 35 days, from the 5 plants each measured for dry biomass
Fold change					Fold change						Fold change						Genotype	Control		+ GA
	Control	+GA				Control	+GA					Control	+GA					Col	prr7prr9	Col	prr7prr9
Col	1	1.1362629727734594			Col	1	1.0392060011290112				Col	1	1.4841852674043208				% water content	91.35384702670714	89.44935523296276	91.72609971438779	90.51424788892419
prr7prr9	0.5257935646358941	1.5840938183920386	0.7330225092673981		prr7prr9	0.5257935646358941	1.5840938183920386	0.8014833772949259			prr7prr9	0.5498366941209887	1.406556390394884	0.6342492192052389			SD	0.1294058346055143	0.4309948682281005	0.3417736068309684	0.46976386446585644


											Calculated Dry biomass, from FW + water content
	Measured Dry biomass										Note SD is also corrected by water content; fractional SD of WC is 10x < biomass						Water content at 35 days, from the 5 plants each measured for dry biomass
Genotype	Control		+ GA		Genotype	Control		+ GA			Genotype	Control		+ GA			Genotype	Control		+ GA
	DW	SD	DW	SD		DW	SD	DW	SD			DW	SD	DW	SD			water content	SD	water content	SD
Col	0.07967999999999997	0.00938013859172664	0.08639999999999995	0.016877944187607647	Col	0.07967999999999997	0.00938013859172664	0.07959999999999995	0.008458920340878842	n=4 non-flowering (=smallest) plants for Col+GA	Col	0.07103391077758296	0.010173943128438459	0.10088839412549006	0.014758522077473149		Col	0.9135384702670715	0.0012940583460551431	0.9172609971438779	0.003417736068309684
prr7prr9	0.051100000000000055	0.00382034029897865	0.07252000000000006	0.004484082960873897	prr7prr9	0.051100000000000055	0.00382034029897865	0.07252000000000006	0.004484082960873897		prr7prr9	0.04766016384001818	0.006722288794840156	0.0733605602015603	0.007921703625623172		prr7prr9	0.8944935523296276	0.004309948682281005	0.9051424788892419	0.004697638644658565

















Fold change					Fold change						Fold change
	Control	+GA				Control	+GA					Control	+GA
Col	1	1.08433734939759			Col	1	0.9989959839357426				Col	1	1.4202849458955684
prr7prr9	0.6413152610441776	1.4191780821917803	0.839351851851853		prr7prr9	0.6413152610441776	1.4191780821917803	0.9110552763819109			prr7prr9	0.6709494566510461	1.5392427195133267	0.7271456824886195


Genotype	Time of Harvest	Treatment	Replicate	chl a (mg/g FW)	mg chl b/g FW	starch (µmol/gFW)	malate (µmol/g FW)	fumarate (µmol/g FW)	glucose (µmol/g FW)	fructose (µmol/g FW)	sucrose (µmol/g FW)	total protein (mg/gFW)	AA (µmol/gFW)	G6P (nmol/g FW)	NO3 (µmol/g FW)
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA	3	0.9654293103448275	0.27856142241379306	60.86563173483617	22.051578894747227	20.820266162189654	0.8043535076742758	0.048261210460456554	2.5256700140972237	16.650060837976678	37.04276507445884	171.62923443025267	99.77794233725606
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA	2	0.9510526315789476	0.3157939473684209	57.96091376316183	21.141807081421465	21.108262822961063	0.7857263738123441	0.058929478035925895	2.1509259483112926	17.85505607477699	36.28237175481116	212.496827889734	104.28177975269723
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA	1	0.9529948497854077	0.2725118025751073	58.30932775629357	22.559474656472812	20.372710544381487	0.7848833197631885	0.03203605386788532	2.4747851612941383	16.847670628849762	36.446916982543705	175.9808018892732	106.53157279831353
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control	3	1.1476068085106386	0.29598510638297876	66.48859542198495	22.929889162216902	20.197539573838366	1.175246044234208	0.25410725280739677	2.961937665536216	17.587649887271517	37.344212898312115	192.5434725006851	110.01626532700409
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control	2	1.2141472081218274	0.32995253807106595	63.53587297809757	21.734491094431327	21.37749037583071	0.9662041322641656	0.18945179064003248	2.7470509642804672	18.888676599468216	36.25504856314755	186.5062529825723	116.66758948568092
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control	1	1.1676736842105264	0.31392511961722486	65.40492131089306	21.80270094730263	21.344051045082523	0.9107282969188528	0.17857417586644211	2.9375451930029697	18.674889045348024	36.82849025204444	196.1164654386272	108.27738622467889
Col0	28D_EoD	GA	3	0.8548381909547739	0.2729150753768844	42.15548115944195	12.30824919622726	10.66745988148153	0.2250573030517773	0.03750955050862955	1.8848549130586336	15.578023516404585	25.82260314279286	185.69425329685265	107.52601481622997
Col0	28D_EoD	GA	2	0.8803286432160805	0.2781444723618091	45.514483642266015	13.063480150096181	10.850343419346075	0.3375859545776659	0.018754775254314775	2.1661765418733534	18.49408606128555	26.299736758938735	183.7278594889554	117.89753129702298
Col0	28D_EoD	GA	1	0.8477218750000003	0.28689374999999995	43.69239974337993	10.959820488964487	8.75552887566591	0.15550834481702666	0.09719271551064167	1.8563808662532544	14.018504235111084	29.3098519015159	160.3812169685926	121.45938236131197
Col0	28D_EoD	Control	3	1.0017508021390376	0.30414438502673785	42.805277495357245	11.587616428163106	7.758111145636126	0.35924922439013646	0	2.005808169511593	17.2443909573377	29.08778231150118	148.08978483455908	137.9045320124502
Col0	28D_EoD	Control	2	1.0921797872340426	0.31970319148936177	44.35535978017446	13.361384724651828	9.039725184254314	0.297781936883667	0	2.819002335832054	18.37901856322067	30.903672347640452	164.6535955280774	143.49295972925094
Col0	28D_EoD	Control	1	1.043138860103627	0.30295725388601025	43.72577130976733	13.337411308873506	8.186705050811012	0.4254321557688605	0	2.33020794409762	20.850630429766788	31.091168442282008	137.53928058145712	146.9804955408885
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA	3	0.8813242718446602	0.28629660194174744	11.762623378869932	10.604806747166652	13.21201380357639	0.23552720185879764	0	1.6215141974124911	14.544072358841875	19.406298671378266	145.91851729357148	112.63278775468353
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA	2	0.914495111111111	0.2709604444444445	12.403303279076884	10.29855658616185	13.646952663494133	0.5971520440973823	0	1.633874342877558	15.0748910791507	18.008042014101328	142.38302793492642	116.41716073083894
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA	1	0.9153973214285717	0.27393437500000006	13.876129229826981	10.976886494129708	12.933790128944793	0.24992412559879282	0	1.632837620578778	16.19412876767602	21.498952755976497	128.7367437019291	133.25304927275934
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control	3	0.9584556603773583	0.2891028301886793	13.085057549246455	11.052387183727575	11.315690443840477	0.14083774624938264	0	1.373168025931479	16.24469446468716	20.324359539836074	133.96449472324758	108.96067396110442
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control	2	0.963306280193237	0.2902768115942028	14.369877529781862	10.426283357706398	11.41928415954468	0.1983294832449036	0	1.5866358659592268	15.586126599446397	21.154192105603318	144.07842162903518	105.7858820464678
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control	1	1.0386125560538118	0.2806979820627801	13.41379231397711	9.196184289347153	11.047354346997604	0.18409956516455175	0	1.5397418177398852	15.036038146511697	20.887388286581732	130.75902821990962	117.8614179766149
Col0	28D_EoN	GA	3	0.8406710659898479	0.2715878172588833	4.071724837047641	4.615966603661459	4.424276744114784	0.13261625344802272	0	1.0135670799241727	14.544192269774706	17.476931660232193	114.72675482732154	136.84349321321181
Col0	28D_EoN	GA	2	0.779376530612245	0.26721301020408156	3.495676180785904	3.826490613636936	3.365788516370767	0.0761673525634395	0	0.8568827163387177	13.737600759213578	15.201298182639448	104.56463711262188	126.59057467623867
Col0	28D_EoN	GA	1	0.7464000000000001	0.26932666666666666	3.17081221551712	4.211459053740693	3.099867577809227	0.11483693155718892	0	0.8708467309753488	14.402604858561421	17.772561718594517	103.31382259452447	135.93326805283553
Col0	28D_EoN	Control	3	0.8856497461928934	0.2829743654822336	3.817242034732165	4.484337918058263	2.790221132618265	0.18945179064003248	0	0.9756767217961672	18.90930114069995	27.71021134747925	138.729035519732	120.6412710321805
Col0	28D_EoN	Control	2	0.8596458715596331	0.2657545871559631	3.3728699242669093	4.256370212778396	2.815997483592719	0.05136055425149504	0	0.9244899765269097	15.161360097047904	23.089790056348843	100.30660724719912	119.93138266949309
Col0	28D_EoN	Control	1	0.9001641509433963	0.27988018867924525	5.990749239414044	4.9614628836533	3.6771158775039	0.10562830968703699	0	1.3995751033532382	17.21669948114947	28.272336830205347	112.36551720153984	127.78052666167044

GA : GA treatment										Value less than 0
EoD: End of Day										Replace these values with 0, but I would tend to not use the Fructose data
EoN: End of Night
D: days
t-test probabilities - <0.05 red font, <0.001 red shading
Genotype	Time of Harvest	Treatment	Compared to	chl a (mg/g FW)	mg chl b/g FW	starch (µmol/gFW)	malate (µmol/g FW)	fumarate (µmol/g FW)	glucose (µmol/g FW)	fructose (µmol/g FW)	sucrose (µmol/g FW)	total protein (mg/gFW)	AA (µmol/gFW)	G6P (nmol/g FW)	NO3 (µmol/g FW)
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA	79 control	4.04734157285686E-4	0.21917099930387235	0.008352749821936263	0.6964556509209041	0.6661749977011575	0.049095912268758		0.021289203734570744	0.08239096641949664	0.6053200233329402	0.7242126655029514	0.06609588414192669
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control	Col control	0.01618918018264071	0.7172617479333336	2.4738113353188373E-5	1.8207022088116863E-4	1.9812507825750367E-5	0.0017668859765353222		0.11327097309218116	0.7182039830706277	8.240958158077054E-4	0.007647742642179798	0.0010660709691512455
Col0	28D_EoD	GA	Col control	0.00271561663570274	0.011879587809494349	0.8893104043294044	0.4863301142791543	0.08349335817962933	0.1332839736163566		0.17984594406432935	0.17342659646001526	0.063756430667524	0.07941471743594027	0.00535128213771977
Col0	28D_EoD	Control
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA	79 control	0.04246470907196895	0.1595583954419658	0.26902836629660215	0.5261869073286742	0.0010430404170715132	0.19364378336633728		0.11657306903261233	0.5889865183424614	0.33193293117724115	0.6987448226731108	0.24638123975028234
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control	Col control	0.02120922356135441	0.16053577249145654	5.008829524250785E-4	6.330849743746013E-4	1.2626581717288142E-5	0.248968936530281		0.0711982218192986	0.2652648406724826	0.028443620929160498	0.18704841488372492	0.053590100322646314
Col0	28D_EoN	GA	Col control	0.03641841428729789	0.27843832319004025	0.3926688917166315	0.3205061348071378	0.3432222508382561	0.8696371158682829		0.3057967293666327	0.061371420893231554	0.006479574876318775	0.46534797704758285	0.06633709453146681
Col0	28D_EoN	Control

Mean
Genotype	Time of Harvest	Treatment	Replicate	chl a (mg/g FW)	mg chl b/g FW	starch (µmol/gFW)	malate (µmol/g FW)	fumarate (µmol/g FW)	glucose (µmol/g FW)	fructose (µmol/g FW)	sucrose (µmol/g FW)	total protein (mg/gFW)	AA (µmol/gFW)	G6P (nmol/g FW)	NO3 (µmol/g FW)
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA		0.956492263903061	0.2889557241191071	59.04529108476385	21.9176202108805	20.767079843177402	0.7916544004166028	0.04640891412142259	2.383793707900885	17.11759584720114	36.59068460393791	186.70228806975328	103.53043162942227
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control		1.1764759002809975	0.3132875880237565	65.14312990365853	22.155693734650285	20.973026998250532	1.0173928244724089	0.20737773977129045	2.8821779409398847	18.38373851069592	36.809250571168036	191.72206364062822	111.65374701245463
Col0	28D_EoD	GA		0.8609629030569516	0.2793177659128978	43.787454848362636	12.110516611762643	10.091110725497838	0.2393838674821566	0.05115234709119534	1.9691374403950805	16.030204604267073	27.14406393441583	176.60110991813357	115.62764282485496
Col0	28D_EoD	Control		1.045689816492236	0.30893494346736994	43.62880286176635	12.76213748722948	8.328180460233817	0.36082110568088793	0	2.385006149813756	18.82467998344172	30.36087436714121	150.09422031469785	142.7926624275299
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA		0.9037389014614478	0.27706380712873063	12.680685295924599	10.62674994248607	13.264252198671771	0.36086779051832424	0	1.629408720289609	15.271030735222865	19.637764480485362	139.012762976809	120.76766591942726
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control		0.9867914988748024	0.2866925412818874	13.62290913100181	10.224951610260375	11.260776316794255	0.17442226488627932	0	1.4998485698768638	15.62228640354842	20.78864664400704	136.26731485739745	110.86932466139571
Col0	28D_EoN	GA		0.788815865534031	0.2693758313765438	3.5794044111168883	4.217972090346363	3.6299776127649257	0.10787351252288373	0	0.9137655090794131	14.228132629183236	16.81693052048872	107.5350715114893	133.12244531409533
Col0	28D_EoN	Control		0.8818199228986409	0.27620304710581395	4.39362039947104	4.56739033816332	3.094444831238295	0.11548021819285485	0	1.099913933892105	17.095786906299107	26.357446078011147	117.13371998949032	122.784393454448

Standard deviation
Genotype	Time of Harvest	Treatment	Replicate	chl a (mg/g FW)	mg chl b/g FW	starch (µmol/gFW)	malate (µmol/g FW)	fumarate (µmol/g FW)	glucose (µmol/g FW)	fructose (µmol/g FW)	sucrose (µmol/g FW)	total protein (mg/gFW)	AA (µmol/gFW)	G6P (nmol/g FW)	NO3 (µmol/g FW)
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	GA		0.007800394362921368	0.023438582410913032	1.5860574199510482	0.7182645996257023	0.37064926416823796	0.011005824770950247	0.013542057346143388	0.2032679565337464	0.6462569905265164	0.40006417842917996	22.444436910535966	3.438935024523207
prr7prr9	28D_EoD	Control		0.03413232267100526	0.01699268780301457	1.4936678055496293	0.6713397545624518	0.6717999004735593	0.13949057788499672	0.04083278299644026	0.117657226913213	0.6976704822718908	0.5448370042854913	4.857476736862782	4.428305250642929
Col0	28D_EoD	GA		0.01714451536571437	0.007062811010674382	1.6815174767578291	1.0656780112620656	1.1602567626632565	0.0918803669470267	0.040960005393782944	0.171233753883084	2.271796419765886	1.8907385490174704	14.081206326975689	7.238713839049514
Col0	28D_EoD	Control		0.04526843127611779	0.009344447237994834	0.7795774062636944	1.017235700223315	0.6524148255514418	0.06383962486930564	0	0.4093572040977033	1.8439634918380272	1.1065085779047463	13.667839622693062	4.578328376764158
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	GA		0.01941687955124499	0.00813292326176565	1.0837122925206208	0.3396969147292047	0.35943961608706365	0.2047547416309406	0	0.006856479918602564	0.8423328389637548	1.7569282192292497	9.073166500982474	10.976974438132302
prr7prr9	28D_EoN	Control		0.04494383832642878	0.0052245203855154935	0.6674488579416827	0.9443374135730384	0.19194951778335473	0.02994265454493693	0	0.11218615378166504	0.6051389695275703	0.423636584569514	6.9518915141455455	6.259940304975776
Col0	28D_EoN	GA		0.04783914979950831	0.002187817878208509	0.45625508251855806	0.39477829150128074	0.700615314519115	0.028861505613097617	0	0.08671224586818285	0.4306714354881997	1.4069648791565674	6.259502050969049	5.675044315502394
Col0	28D_EoN	Control		0.02052884314578079	0.009179935675960153	1.4008861629958012	0.3598085560327275	0.504772489528284	0.06957077308564266	0	0.2607731448691102	1.876893818184876	2.843796436370218	19.650001703810307	4.341312663250915

Mean		mg/g FW	mg/g FW	umol C6/gFW	umol C4/gFW	umol C4/gFW	umol/gFW	umol/gFW	umol/gFW	mg/gFW	umol/gFW	nmol/gFW	umol/gFW	umol C/gFW	umol C/gFW	umol C/gFW
Treatment	Genotype	chl a	chl b	Starch	Malate	Fumarate	Glucose	Fructose	Sucrose	Total protein	AA	G6P	NO3	Starch	Malate	Fumarate
Control	Col ED	1.045689816492236	0.30893494346736994	43.62880286176635	12.76213748722948	8.328180460233817	0.36082110568088793	0	2.385006149813756	18.82467998344172	30.36087436714121	150.09422031469785	142.7926624275299	261.7728171705981	51.04854994891792	33.31272184093527	Col Ctl
Control	Col EN	0.8818199228986409	0.27620304710581395	4.39362039947104	4.56739033816332	3.094444831238295	0.11548021819285485	0	1.099913933892105	17.095786906299107	26.357446078011147	117.13371998949032	122.784393454448	26.361722396826238	18.26956135265328	12.37777932495318	Col GA
GA	Col ED	0.8609629030569516	0.2793177659128978	43.787454848362636	12.110516611762643	10.091110725497838	0.2393838674821566	0.05115234709119534	1.9691374403950805	16.030204604267073	27.14406393441583	176.60110991813357	115.62764282485496	262.7247290901758	48.44206644705057	40.36444290199135	prr Ctl
GA	Col EN	0.788815865534031	0.2693758313765438	3.5794044111168883	4.217972090346363	3.6299776127649257	0.10787351252288373	0	0.9137655090794131	14.228132629183236	16.81693052048872	107.5350715114893	133.12244531409533	21.47642646670133	16.87188836138545	14.519910451059703	prr GA
Control	prr7prr9 ED	1.1764759002809975	0.3132875880237565	65.14312990365853	22.155693734650285	20.973026998250532	1.0173928244724089	0.20737773977129045	2.8821779409398847	18.38373851069592	36.809250571168036	191.72206364062822	111.65374701245463	390.8587794219512	88.62277493860114	83.89210799300213
Control	prr7prr9 EN	0.9867914988748024	0.2866925412818874	13.62290913100181	10.224951610260375	11.260776316794255	0.17442226488627932	0	1.4998485698768638	15.62228640354842	20.78864664400704	136.26731485739745	110.86932466139571	81.73745478601086	40.8998064410415	45.04310526717702
GA	prr7prr9 ED	0.956492263903061	0.2889557241191071	59.04529108476385	21.9176202108805	20.767079843177402	0.7916544004166028	0.04640891412142259	2.383793707900885	17.11759584720114	36.59068460393791	186.70228806975328	103.53043162942227	354.27174650858313	87.670480843522	83.06831937270961
GA	prr7prr9 EN	0.9037389014614478	0.27706380712873063	12.680685295924599	10.62674994248607	13.264252198671771	0.36086779051832424	0	1.629408720289609	15.271030735222865	19.637764480485362	139.012762976809	120.76766591942726	76.0841117755476	42.50699976994428	53.057008794687086


SD		mg/g FW	mg/g FW	umol C6/gFW	umol C4/gFW	umol C4/gFW	umol/gFW	umol/gFW	umol/gFW	mg/gFW	umol/gFW	nmol/gFW	umol/gFW	umol C/gFW	umol C/gFW	umol C/gFW
Treatment	Genotype	chl a	chl b	Starch	Malate	Fumarate	Glucose	Fructose	Sucrose	Total protein	AA	G6P	NO3	Starch	Malate	Fumarate
Control	Col ED	0.04526843127611779	0.009344447237994834	0.7795774062636944	1.017235700223315	0.6524148255514418	0.06383962486930564	0	0.4093572040977033	1.8439634918380272	1.1065085779047463	13.667839622693062	4.578328376764158	4.677464437582167	4.06894280089326	2.6096593022057673
Control	Col EN	0.02052884314578079	0.009179935675960153	1.4008861629958012	0.3598085560327275	0.504772489528284	0.06957077308564266	0	0.2607731448691102	1.876893818184876	2.843796436370218	19.650001703810307	4.341312663250915	8.405316977974806	1.43923422413091	2.019089958113136
GA	Col ED	0.01714451536571437	0.007062811010674382	1.6815174767578291	1.0656780112620656	1.1602567626632565	0.0918803669470267	0.040960005393782944	0.171233753883084	2.271796419765886	1.8907385490174704	14.081206326975689	7.238713839049514	10.089104860546975	4.2627120450482625	4.641027050653026
GA	Col EN	0.04783914979950831	0.002187817878208509	0.45625508251855806	0.39477829150128074	0.700615314519115	0.028861505613097617	0	0.08671224586818285	0.4306714354881997	1.4069648791565674	6.259502050969049	5.675044315502394	2.7375304951113484	1.579113166005123	2.80246125807646
Control	prr7prr9 ED	0.03413232267100526	0.01699268780301457	1.4936678055496293	0.6713397545624518	0.6717999004735593	0.13949057788499672	0.04083278299644026	0.117657226913213	0.6976704822718908	0.5448370042854913	4.857476736862782	4.428305250642929	8.962006833297776	2.685359018249807	2.6871996018942372
Control	prr7prr9 EN	0.04494383832642878	0.0052245203855154935	0.6674488579416827	0.9443374135730384	0.19194951778335473	0.02994265454493693	0	0.11218615378166504	0.6051389695275703	0.423636584569514	6.9518915141455455	6.259940304975776	4.004693147650096	3.7773496542921534	0.7677980711334189
GA	prr7prr9 ED	0.007800394362921368	0.023438582410913032	1.5860574199510482	0.7182645996257023	0.37064926416823796	0.011005824770950247	0.013542057346143388	0.2032679565337464	0.6462569905265164	0.40006417842917996	22.444436910535966	3.438935024523207	9.516344519706289	2.8730583985028093	1.4825970566729518
GA	prr7prr9 EN	0.01941687955124499	0.00813292326176565	1.0837122925206208	0.3396969147292047	0.35943961608706365	0.2047547416309406	0	0.006856479918602564	0.8423328389637548	1.7569282192292497	9.073166500982474	10.976974438132302	6.502273755123725	1.3587876589168189	1.4377584643482546